Call Us
One of the top questions homeowners ask is:
“Should I sell my home or rent it out?”
The right answer depends on your goals, the market, and — of course — the math.
Start With Your Goals (“Define Your Goals”)
Step 1: Define Your Goals
Short-term cash vs. long-term wealth
Lifestyle, time, and risk tolerance
First, think about what you really want.
Are you looking for a quick payout to buy your next home?
Or are you more interested in building long-term wealth and passive income?
There’s no wrong answer — but your goal shapes everything that follows.
Pros & Cons of Selling (“If You Sell…”)
If You Sell:
✅ Instant cash-out
✅ Simpler, no tenant management
❌ Lose future appreciation
❌ Pay taxes and selling costs
If you sell, the benefits are pretty clear:
You get your equity out now.
You avoid managing tenants or maintenance.
But on the flip side:
You lose out on potential appreciation.
You’ll pay closing costs, commissions, and possibly capital gains taxes.
Pros & Cons of Renting (“If You Rent…”)
If You Rent:
✅ Build long-term wealth
✅ Tenant pays your mortgage
✅ Tax benefits
❌ Requires management
❌ Vacancy & repair risk
Renting can be a great path to long-term wealth.
Your tenant covers your mortgage, your property can appreciate, and you get tax benefits like depreciation.
But — it does come with headaches:
Vacancies, maintenance, and tenant issues.
If you manage it yourself, it’s active work.
If you hire a professional property manager, you’ll trade some income for peace of mind.
The “Simple” Math (“The 1% Rule Example”)
The 1% Rule
Rent ≈ 1% of Purchase Price
Example:
$400,000 Home → $4,000/mo Rent = Good
$400,000 Home → $2,500/mo Rent = Maybe Not
One quick rule of thumb investors use is the 1% rule.
If the monthly rent is about 1% of the home’s value, the property often makes sense as a rental.
So a $400,000 home should rent for around $4,000 a month to hit that target.
If it’s closer to $2,500, it might not cash flow unless you have a low mortgage balance.
Pro Insight: The 1% Rule is pretty hard to obtain these days, but everyone still references it as a bench mark for comparison. Ultimately you need to calculate what your current mortgage and expenses are and what the potential rent could be to be able to evaluate if your property might make a good rental based on your current situation and long term goals.
Net Cash Flow (“Basic Cash Flow Formula”)
Cash Flow = Rent – Expenses
Example:
Rent: $2,500
Mortgage: $1,800
Taxes & Insurance: $300
Maintenance: $150
Management: $200
= +$50/month
The best way to decide is to look at your monthly cash flow.
Take your rent and subtract all expenses — mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and management.
If it’s positive, you’re building wealth every month.
If it’s negative, you’re subsidizing a tenant to live there — and it might make more sense to sell.
Pro Tip: Just keep in mind that cash flow is not the only factor. There are 4 wealth drivers in real estate for long term wealth creation and cash flow is just one of the four.
Long-Term Equity Growth (“Long-Term Payoff”)
Long-Term Payoff:
Mortgage Paydown
Appreciation
Tax Benefits
Even if cash flow is small now, every month your tenant pays down your mortgage — and your equity grows.
Over 10–15 years, that can add up to tens or even hundreds of thousands in wealth — especially if the market appreciates.
When Selling Might Be Better (“When Selling Wins”)
Sell if…
You need equity now
The property won’t cash flow
Major repairs are coming
You’re moving far away
Selling might make more sense if you need cash for your next move, if the home won’t have cash flow, or if major repairs are due soon.
It’s also a good idea if you’re moving far away and don’t want the hassle of managing a property remotely.
Need Help Deciding?
If you’re unsure whether to sell or rent, our team can run the numbers for you — including expected rent, management costs, and net return.
